Your ads will be inserted here by
Easy Plugin for AdSense.
Please go to the plugin admin page to
Paste your ad code OR
Suppress this ad slot.
Yesterday, ESPN came out with their Hall of 100, a neat idea where they basically try to name the 100 best player in baseball history. It was an update from one they did last year, so maybe that’s why I didn’t see quite the fanfare this time. But I still love the idea, and this kind of thing is just made for debate and criticism.
Last night I went through the list and made some comments on Twitter. I didn’t make a comment on all of the players, but here’s what struck me at the time:
Gut feeling: Eckersley, #117, doesn't belong on list. Also, just call it Hall of 125. Obsession with round numbers is BBWAA-esque #hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#115: George Sisler. What an incredibly forgotten great player. .340 career average, much of it in the deadball era. 2x over .400
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#114: Bill Dickey. Calling him a "second-tier star" is a travesty. Top 5-10 catcher ever.
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#114: Roy Halladay. With 90.4% to go, I doubt I'll see a better photo than this one
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
(Obviously a typo here – Halladay was #113)
#111: Pud Galvin. Patron saint of Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#106: Whitey Ford. I don't care with this list, JAWS or WAR says, Ford was better than this. Just ask my Dad.
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#98: Joe Cronin. Led the DC baseball to its most recent WS appearance. In 1933. Long enough already! #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#96: Tim Raines. JAWS has him as the 8th best LFer. That's since ever. Underrated here #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#91 Craig Biggio. I have some trouble with this one. Deserves to be one of the 300-ish in the HoF, don't think he's top 100 #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#89 Cap Anson. His HOF plaque should mention his key role in segregation. More important to mention than Clemens/Bonds PED use #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#86 Manny Ramirez. I know, steroids and all that, but how good of a hitter was he? .323/.419/.615 over EIGHT seasons (97-04) #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#76 John Smoltz. Was he really THIS great? Remarkable career/story but another guy who I think is a HOFer, but not quite top 100. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#72 Ivan Rodriguez. Under rate. Sick arm plus absolutely incredible offense for his position. Only C I'd rank higher is Bench #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#61 Bob Feller. "Sorry I had 105 Ws by age 23 (yup) then lost 3.5 years fighting the war in the Pacific. Guess that hurt my WAR" #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
Feller’s numbers were hurt, like many others of his time, by having to leave the game for 3 1/2 years. In Feller’s case, the 3 seasons prior to shipping off, he won 24, 27 and 25 games, respectively. The two years after: 26 and 20. Probably missed about 1200 IP in his absolute prime, possible 90 wins.
#60 Robin Yount. Imagine if Derek Jeter had moved to CF in 2003. More pop and less AVG and that's basically Yount. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#58 Yogi Berra. Thanks ESPN for using this forum to expose the world to Yogi-isms isn't of talking about his career. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
Typo here as well, shoulda been “instead isn’t of talking about his career”. So, joke ruined! Athankew
#54. Jackie Robinson. This feels low, but it's probably right. He was a great 2B, but maybe not top 5, and that's where we are #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#51 Pete Alexander. Why are we calling him this? I grew up learning about Grover Cleveland Alexander. That's a name you remember #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
Seriously, can someone tell me when this happened? I didn’t even know who Pete Alexander was when I saw his name. Grover Cleveland Alexander, I’ve known that name since I was 6. But Pete?
#48 Lefty Grove. This is an underrate. More dominant in his time than some of the others that will probably be named later #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
Your ads will be inserted here by
Easy Plugin for AdSense.
Please go to the plugin admin page to
Paste your ad code OR
Suppress this ad slot.
Lefty Grove here is perhaps biggest lowball of the whole thing.
#42 Eddie Collins. Best 2B behind the untouchable Hornsby. Why are almost all great 2B pre-WWII? Get on that, Rendon. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#41 Pedro Martinez. Love Pedro. Peak was incredible. Definite HOFer. Not better than Lefty Grove. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#36 Nolan Ryan. Walked SO MANY guys and such an up and down pitcher. But when he was on… extra credit for 7 No Nos #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#28 Jimmie Foxx. .332/.438/.634 over THIRTEEN seasons (29-41). Inspiration for Hanks character in League of Their Own #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#27 Johnny Bench. Catchers get a raw deal. 27 is too low for the best one ever, and if another C ranks higher, they screwed up #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#23 Randy Johnson. THE dominant SP for 4-5 yrs. Prepare to hear how historically good, next HOF vote. You're lucky you saw him. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#20 Joe Morgan. This is a miss, he's 3rd best 2B behind Collins. More HRs in a much more hitter-friendly era, nothing else better #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#16 Albert Pujols. I think his reputation will improve, as last 3 yrs are making many forget how dominant he was for 1st 10 #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#15 Rogers Hornsby. This smells like an underrate. How can he be out of the top 10? Starter on the all time top 9 #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#12 Walter Johnson. No, this is wrong. Best SP ever, better than Clemens. Better peak. longer career, more dominant in his time #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#11 Lou Gehrig. An insult to a legend and a Columbia alum. Starting 9 all time. Probably top 5 for me #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#10 Honus Wagner. Another underrate? Best player ever at most important position. 8 batting titles and 6 SLUGGING titles #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#9 Mickey Mantle. Good spot for maybe the most talented player ever. A switch hitting, faster (initially) @Bharper3407 #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#8 Stan Musial. Underappreciated, to the point of being overrated (here). Top 20 player EVER, but doesn't beat Honus or Hornsby #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#7 Roger Clemens. As previously stated, I don't think he quite belongs here. At least not ahead of WJ. Top 20, just not 7 #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#5 Hank Aaron. I'd probably move Aaron down a bit here as well. Gets extra credit for the HR record. More like top 10/12 to me. #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#3 Barry Bonds. We know he had help, but my god, those numbers from 2001-2004. And 1990-1998 for that matter #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#2 Willie Mays. Yup. Greatest real life player ever. Did everything well #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
#1 Babe Ruth. Greatest fictional player ever. Nobody could've REALLY been a top 10 SP, then been the best hitter for 13 season #Hallof100
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
From 1919-1932, Ruth hit .354/.487/.726. In those 14 seasons, he lead the league in OBP 10x, SLG 12x, and had an OBP over .500 5x.
— Charlie F (@nationalsreview) January 11, 2014
Babe Ruth was good. No way that was a real person.